Search results

  1. David Harper CFA FRM

    EVT Learning objective

    Hi @gitusrini We think you do not need to know how to calculate GEV/POT for the exam ... see https://forum.bionicturtle.com/threads/p2-t7-804-extreme-value-theory-evt-approaches-dowd-ch-7.13994/post-74861 i.e.,
  2. David Harper CFA FRM

    Calculation of Tail VaR in ES and Normal Deviate in Spectral Measure

    Hi @julienfrancaoui Yea this is a basic skill that is already much-discussed in the forum; e.g., see https://forum.bionicturtle.com/threads/probability-function.23487/post-83885 See below. The Z-lookup table gives you the relationship between N(z) = p; for example (see red below) N(-2.33) =...
  3. David Harper CFA FRM

    Chapter12: Measuring returns, volatility and correlation

    No, they are in T4 but they should be also restored to T2 (GARCH is highly testable, a perennial exam favorite), see post and link at https://forum.bionicturtle.com/threads/p1-t2-324-estimating-volatility-topic-review.7277/post-83204 i.e.,
  4. David Harper CFA FRM

    Mean variance analysis

    Hi @Akriti1 Yikes, I agree with you, this question is flawed. At a minimum, it seems the construction is insufficient. The answer is not (C). We should expect the Portfolio to lie on the SML because we can expect any portfolio to lie on the SML per my personal favorite distinction, see e.g...
  5. David Harper CFA FRM

    We have been acquired by CeriFi

    I wanted to share some exciting news: Bionic Turtle has been acquired by CeriFi. You can read the press release here https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/cerifi-a-portfolio-company-of-leeds-equity-partners-completes-acquisition-of-bionic-turtle-301242071.html. I started BT over 15 years ago...
  6. David Harper CFA FRM

    Information Ratio

    Thank you @RajivBoolell It's true @tornellFRM GARP allows for two valid IRs. In addition please see Note: https://forum.bionicturtle.com/threads/information-ratio-definition.5554/ or Video: https://forum.bionicturtle.com/threads/t1-11-information-ratio.21447/
  7. David Harper CFA FRM

    Question about Binomial Trees

    Hi @Pandeyg Please see below; I did input GARP's T4 EOC 14.5 into my binomial XLS (see here https://www.dropbox.com/s/36lt46xkqgkf0k8/garp-t4-eoc-14-15.xlsx?dl=0 ) GARP's solution looks correct to me. The u = 1.1052 = exp[20.0% * sqrt(3/12)], so the annual (aka, per annum) volatility is being...
  8. David Harper CFA FRM

    CFA Institute vs GARP

    Hi @jwagner88 Thank you for sharing your email. Both of your concerns are valid (who could argue with either?). I do continue to be disappointed--over a decade later--that [apparently none of] the Trustees continue to be uninterested in "eating their own dog food." It is sort of astonishing to...
  9. David Harper CFA FRM

    Bias of the variance

    Hi @librosdeholanda You make a good point, strictly speaking the bias of the sample variance is negative: (n-1)/n*σ^2 - σ^2 =(n-1)/n*σ^2 - σ^2*n/n = σ^2*[(n-1)-n]/n = σ^2*(-1)/n = -σ^2/n ... although we barely need the math: intuitively, the biased (MLE) variance divides by n, while the...
  10. David Harper CFA FRM

    P1.T4 Ch 6 Credit Risk & Capital Modeling

    Hi @etzaros 1. I think we just followed GARP's goofy example in 6.6 where implicitly the weights are $1.0 rather than 33.3%. Notice their equation doesn't square any weights in referencing their 6.1 [sic] and only subsequently assumes all loans are the same size. So I think we just assumed all...
  11. David Harper CFA FRM

    CVA Questions

    Hi @danghara First, please note that any bilateral derivative contract always must have one counterparty who has zero credit exposure, right? Exposure = max(value, 0). If you and me enter into an interest rate swap, the initial value will be zero (aka, par transaction). Whichever way the rate...
  12. David Harper CFA FRM

    Chapter 5 Margin requirements for short Options

    Hi @NEichi The formula is correct per Hull (who is GARP's ultimate source here) ... ... but, I agree with you, GARP's interim formula has a typo. For the naked written call, it should be as follows (although the result is the same): max(5 + 0.2 * 47 - 3, 5 + 0.1 * 47) = 11.4. Great catch on...
  13. David Harper CFA FRM

    VaR is not subadditivity, yet there is formula for diversified VaR?

    Hi @Guannn the diversified portfolio VaR assumes the classic mean-variance framework (aka, MPT) which assumes returns are normally distributed (why? because it only cares about means, variances and correlations; not skew or kurtosis). The normal distribution is subadditive: mixing assets with...
  14. David Harper CFA FRM

    Calculation of Tail VaR in ES and Normal Deviate in Spectral Measure

    Hi @julienfrancaoui Please see below (I think this is the table/illustration to which you refer?). Please allow me to make two corrections to your example ... First, the confidence level for both VaR and expected shortfall (ES) is always one-tailed. So, a 99.00% CL refers to one-tail CL such...
  15. David Harper CFA FRM

    Difference between RAROC and ARAROC

    Hi @sohinichowdhury I like your question, but I didn't quite "agree" because I have a slightly different interpretation(s), and I acknowledge there seem to be two different, valid interpretations of ARAROC, depending on whether we refer to the simpler Crouhy or the more difficult Grinold...
  16. David Harper CFA FRM

    Grinold, Chapter 14: Portfolio Construction

    Hi @sajedian I frankly cannot recall where Grindold infers that "in the example effectively shrank the IC by 62%", sorry. Per the related discussion (and GARP's practice question) at...
  17. David Harper CFA FRM

    CAPM - Formulation for CAPM

    Hi Navjyot (@navjyotbirdy) I think it's a good question. My sense is there may be an easy answer and a harder answer. The easy answer is that the market portfolio must have a beta of 1.0 by definition of CAPM's beta! We can think of generic beta as a re-scaled correlation between two assets: the...
  18. David Harper CFA FRM

    COLLATERAL : Calculation of Credit Support Amount

    Hi @thanhtam92 You are correct they go in opposite directions (because the "+" switches to a "-"), but I think it's the inverse of what you wrote. This exhibit replicates (and collapses) Gregory's Tables 6.3 and 6.4, as noted in the header. Assume we are the Financial Institution (FI) and our...
  19. David Harper CFA FRM

    Exam Feedback January 2021 Part 1 Exam Feedback (postponed 2020 exam)

    About this Bayes Question, more than one person has contacted me privately. I'm told the question is something like the following (I'm not sure about the exact text, but let's focus only on the numeric assumptions): If that's the question, setting aside some potential awkwardness in the...
  20. David Harper CFA FRM

    Chi Square p value

    Hi @haziqmn Because the p-value is a tail probability, it is an inverse distribution function and, as such, requires an (Excel or other) function call. It is analogous to, using the more familiar normal distribution being given the quantile (aka, deviate) of 2.33 and retrieving the probability...
Top